When resilience becomes toxic

In today’s fast-moving and competitive workplace, the idea of resilience, of bouncing back and remaining positive in the face of adversity or stress, is seen as an important attribute. But, with the world of work constantly changing and ongoing disruption and uncertainty, being consistently upbeat can take a real toll on mental health and emotional well-being. At this point resilience can become toxic.

The idea of toxic resilience centres on the expectation that employees should be able to deal with stress, pressure, and adversity by hiding their human vulnerabilities. Despite adverse situations such as ineffective organisational culture, inept management, or ongoing under resourcing, high workloads, and lack of work life boundaries, they keep going and stay productive!

This type of culture puts pressure on employees to keep quiet when they’re overwhelmed or struggling. They don’t feel able to ask for help or raise their concerns because if they do, they are made to feel that they are letting their colleagues down, are incompetent or weak, or simply aren’t resilient enough. A culture of fear then develops, and employees start to put their own needs behind that of the organisation, going beyond their limits and adopting unhealthy coping mechanisms that can have severe and long-lasting effects, and lead to burnout, mental health issues and decreased morale.

It's therefore important that leaders are able to recognise if a culture of toxic resilience is emerging and can instead start to build an environment where healthy resilience can develop. This means creating a culture where authenticity and open communication is valued, mental health resources provided, and managers enabled with the training to support their team and to understand the importance of their own mental health and wellbeing.

Resilience shouldn’t be needed to get through every day, it should be drawn on in the short term, when challenges arise, or problems have to be overcome. If leaders want to create workplaces that foster growth, fulfilment, and well-being, they need to lose the culture of toxic resilience.

Q & A Session - January 2924

Keywords

Resilience – Toxic Resilience – Burnout – Leadership Styles - Adaptability

In this episode of Resilience Unravelled Dr Russell Thackeray answers some resilience-based questions that have been put to him recently by listeners. This is the first podcast Dr Thackeray has done in this format and he covers a range of subjects including toxic resilience and how it relates to leadership, how toxic resilience can lead to burnout, different styles of leadership and the relationship between adaptability and resilience.

Main topics

  • What toxic resilience is and its connection to toxic leadership.

  • Why toxic resilience is the result of leaders expecting constant strength and performance from their employees without considering their well-being.

  • How toxic resilience can lead to burnout and a loss of energy needed for the job.

  • The importance of adapting leadership style to fit individual needs and situations

  • Why effective leadership is adaptable and driven by the task requirements, available resources, time constraints, and risk levels.

  • The difference between resilience and adaptability and why adaptability is a subset of resilience.

Timestamps

1. Introductions - 00:02-00 - 00:46

2. Question 1. Is there such a thing as toxic resilience? -  01:11-04:39

3. Question 2. What would Dr Thackeray’s preferred style of leadership be? - 05:48-09:11

4. Question 3. Is there a link between adaptability and resilience? - 12:02-13:47

5. Predictions and Expectations for 2024 - 13:58-18:40

6. Conclusion and Invitation for more Questions - 18:41-18:54

Action items

  • If you have any questions for future Q&A sessions, please send them to info@qedod.com

  You can listen to the podcast in full and find out further information here. Our upcoming guest list is also available along with our previous blogs.
Find out more about our innovative Resilience and Burnout solutions.